Deportation Defense for Non-Lawful Permanent Residents

When you are in deportation you need to find a way to stop it, and ideally a path to lawful permanent residency. One of the most common defenses is called cancellation of removal. If you do not have lawful status in the United States, your specific requirements will differ from those of lawful permanent residents (green card holders) and citizens who naturalized.

Background Image: Handwoven Shawl, Mali

Published: 10-4-2019

Immigration law is always changing. We will do our best to keep our website as up-to-date as possible, but the latest information might be more readily available at USCIS.gov. These pages were written to help you better understand your legal options, however, none of the information published by Catholic Charities Milwaukee should be considered legal advice. If you plan to open your own immigration case, hire an immigration attorney to consult you personally.

Cancellation of Removal

Deportation Defense for Undocumented Immigrants

If you are not a lawful permanent resident yet, you can apply for something called cancellation of removal. Not only does cancellation stop your deportation, but it also gets you lawful permanent residency, or a green card. However, cancellation of removal is not something you can request outside of a deportation hearing. Cancellation of removal is only an option as a defense to being deported, or removed.

Requirements for Cancellation of Removal

During your deportation hearing, you need to show the judge that you qualify for cancellation by proving that you fulfill the following three requirements:

Continuous Physical Presence

First, you must show that you have been inside of the United States for ten years. This is called continuous physical presence. If you left the United States in the past ten years, you can still show continuous physical presence if:

  • No single trip lasted more than 90 days; and
  • All of your trips combined did not last more than 180 days.

The court will not help you look for evidence of continuous physical presence. However, you can use anything that shows you have been here. Learn more in our Proving Continuous Presence or Residence blog post.

PLEASE NOTE: You stop accruing the ten years needed as soon as you receive a notice to go to court. Alternatively, you stop accruing your time as soon as you commit any crime that puts you into deportation.

Good Moral Character

You will not be granted cancellation of removal unless you prove that you are a person of good moral character. The law does not specify what good moral character is exactly, but it does mention what prevents you from having good moral character. A good way to prove your character will be through sworn statements from family and friends who can vouch for you. We discuss this topic in more detail in our Good Moral Character blog post.

Show Extreme and Unusual Hardship

Lastly, to qualify for cancellation of removal, you must show that your deportation would cause extreme and unusual hardship to at least one eligible family member. An eligible family member can include your:

  • Child who is unmarried, under the age of 21, and either a lawful permanent resident or United States citizen;
  • Parent who is either a lawful permanent resident or United States citizen; or
  • Spouse who is either a lawful permanent resident or United States citizen.

Immigration courts have said that extreme and unusual hardship must be more than the typical hardship that you might expect of someone’s deportation. Your family member cannot just struggle after your hypothetical deportation, but must truly face extreme and unusual hardship. For example, one court ruled that losing your home and all family ties is not considered extreme or unusual because anyone should expect to lose their home and all family ties with a deportation. Don’t take this lightly. Look for any and all of the evidence that you can possibly find. 

Acceptable forms of extreme and unusual hardship will vary depending on which family member your deportation would affect.

General

  • If you were deported, who could care for the child or pay for childcare? Would your spouse be able to afford caring for your child if you were deported?
  • How old is your child? Are they settled in school? Do they have lots of ties to the community and friends? Are all their friends and family in the United States? Are they close to their cousins, grandparents, and aunts and uncles?
  • Does your child have any illness for which they are being treated? Does your child qualify for health insurance in your home country?

Education

  • Does your child have any special education needs? Is there an Individualized Education Plan (IEP)? Would this special education be available in your home country?
  • Is your child trying to go to college? Could they pay for it without your presence in the United States? If your child went with you back to your home country, could they get the same quality of education there?
  • Does your child have activities, sports and hobbies here in the United States? For example, do they play varsity soccer or participate in intramural academic programs? Would any of these activities lead to a college scholarship?

Culture

  • Does your child speak the language in your home country?
  • Does your child have permission to enter and live in your home country? If not, your child might have to be an undocumented person in your home country.

Care Plan

  • Is your parent older and, as a result, you help care for them? Do you take your older parent to medical appointments, assist with banking, and with paying bills?
  • Do you live with your parent in order to better take care of them?
  • Are you your parent’s only child in the United States? Is there anyone else who could help to care for them?
  • Does your parent have any illnesses, or are they beginning to have any cognitive problems?

Financial

  • Is your parent economically dependent on you?
  • Would your parent be able to get their pension or social security payments sent to another country?
  • Is Medicare your parent’s only option for health insurance?

Employment

  • Does your spouse have a job that requires some kind of license? For example, a law license from Wisconsin cannot be used in Burkina Faso, nor could a realtor’s license from Wisconsin be used in Mexico. In other words, if your spouse was required to move to another country, would their ability to make a living be severely harmed?
  • Are your spouse’s job skills transferable to your home country?  For example, we may need bilingual Spanish/English social workers here, but there is not the same kind of demand in Mexico.
  • Would you spouses’ age make if difficult to start a new job or career? Some workers as young as 50 are considered older workers in some countries, which would make landing a job in their field exceedingly difficult, if not impossible.

Health

  • Does your spouse have any medical conditions which would not be adequately addressed in your home country?

Family Connections

  • Does your spouse have children from a previous relationship who cannot leave the United States? Would your spouse be required to choose between living with you or raising their children?
  • Does your spouse have all of their family in the United States? Do they take care of their parents, are all of their brothers and sisters here, or do they have a strong social network here?

Culture

  • Would your spouse be eligible to live in your home country, or would they become an undocumented immigrant there?
  • Does your spouse speak the language in your home country?

YOUR CHILD MUST REMAIN UNMARRIED
AND STILL BE UNDER THE AGE OF 21

Children can only be used as qualifying relatives for cancellation of removal as long as they are under the age of 21 and remain unmarried. Until the day the judge grants you lawful permanent residency, your child must continue to meet these two requirements. Make sure you stay on top of your application so that your child does not age out during the process. Also, make sure your child understands that they must wait to get married until the day you are granted lawful permanent residency.

Filing Your Evidence

You will need to work closely with your immigration attorney to gather evidence and prepare a detailed statement about each aspect of your case. Documents such as medical, tax, and school records are all typically used as evidence. You will also need to submit birth and marriage certificates to the court. Sometimes obtaining these documents can take a while, so request them as soon as possible.

DO NOT PROCRASTINATE

Give these materials to your attorney as soon as possible because the immigration court has very strict filing deadlines. You do not want to lose your case because you procrastinated for too long.

Deportation Hearing

After you submit your statement and evidence, your attorney will present your case to the court before an immigration judge. Then you will wait for a decision following your hearing. By law, Immigration gives only 5,000 final decisions every year, but so many people are in deportation that Immigration regularly exceeds the decision limit. Stay in close contact with your attorney after your hearing in case there are any additional steps you need to take before a final approval.

Once your cancellation of removal application is approved, you will eventually get your lawful permanent resident card in the mail. It should be backdated to the date of your final approval. Waiting for your card will likely seem like a long time, but don’t worry. Once you get your final approval, you are a lawful permanent resident of the United States. However, do not travel until you have proof of your residency, or the physical copy of your green card.

Deportable Crimes

You May Not Qualify for Cancellation if:

Even if you meet the three requirements listed above, if you have committed any of the following crimes, you probably have to find another way to stop your deportation. 

Some of these crimes seem pretty serious, and some much less so. For example, writing a bad check is considered a crime of moral turpitude, or going against good values. Many terms used to define these crimes are confusing. This is why it is important for you to have a good criminal lawyer who is willing to work with an experienced immigration attorney. 

This is not a complete list of crimes that can prevent an undocumented immigrant from qualifying for cancellation of removal, but they are the most common: 

1. Violating a restraining order

Courts can give you a restraining order, which forbids you to have contact with someone. This includes asking someone else to contact the person who filed the order against you. The United States takes restraining orders very seriously. If you violate a restraining order you can be deported, even if you have been a lawful permanent resident for decades.

2. Domestic violence

Although many countries do not prosecute domestic violence crimes, the United States does. If you are convicted of a domestic violence crime, you may become deported. A prosecutor or judge will not treat you less harshly simply because a conviction could lead to your deportation.

3. Child abuse, neglect, or abandonment

What might be appropriate child discipline in your home country might be considered domestic violence in the United States. You can be criminally charged for hitting your children, or using a belt or a stick to discipline them. If convicted for child abuse, you could be put into deportation. This does not mean you cannot discipline your children, but hitting them is not legally acceptable in the United States.

4. Stalking

5. Falsely claiming United States citizenship

Many applications may ask if you are a United States citizen, including job, housing, and immigration forms. NEVER say that you are a United States citizen unless you are actually a United States citizen. Even if you have passed the citizenship test, you are not a United States citizen until your swearing in ceremony. Never lie about being a United States citizen.

6. Voting before you are a United States citizen

Do not vote or register to vote unless you are a United States citizen. Sometimes before elections, people will try to help others register to vote in their district. However, unless you are a citizen, if you vote or register to vote, you can become deportable.

7. Conviction for a controlled substance

If you have more than one offense for possession of 30 grams or less of marijuana, you are deportable. 

If you have one offense for possession of 30 grams or more of marijuana you are deportable. 

Even though a number of states have legalized marijuana use, it is still considered illegal by Immigration and the U.S. federal government. 

8. Drug abuse or addiction

9. Failure to tell Immigration that you have moved, and have a new address

If you change addresses, Immigration requires that you inform them within ten days of moving, or you are deportable. This rule applies to anyone who is not a United States citizen. You can update your address with USCIS on their website.

10. Failure to register as a sex offender

Certain convictions require you to register as a sex offender and keep your registry current. If you have been convicted of a crime that requires you to register as a sex offender and you do not, you can be deported. 

11. Conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude

Moral turpitude means that someone has done something so bad that their community would consider it shocking, or evil. The term confuses most people, but examples of crimes of moral turpitude include: murder, kidnapping, robbery, and aggravated assault (threatening someone’s safety).

12. Aggravated felony

Anyone can be deported if they are convicted of an aggravated felony at any time. However, the State of Wisconsin often defines aggravated felony very differently than Immigration. In other words, if the state doesn’t charge you with aggravated felony, it doesn’t automatically mean that Immigration won’t.

For Immigration, a deportable, aggravated felony can include any of the following convictions:

Theft

  • burglary or theft offenses, including receipt of stolen property, for which the term of imprisonment could be at least one year;
  • racketeering (taking money or property through intimidation or force);
  • commercial bribery, counterfeiting, forgery, or trafficking of vehicles, or altering vehicle identification numbers, for which the term of imprisonment is at least one year;
  • an offense relating to laundering of money or monetary instruments if the amount of the funds exceeds $10,000;
  • fraud or deceit in which the loss to the victim(s) exceeds $10,000;
  • tax evasion in which the revenue loss to the Government exceeds $10,000;

Weapons and Drugs

  • any offense relating to explosive materials;
  • trafficking in firearms or destructive devices, or selling guns or destructive devices such as bombs;
  • certain firearm crimes of violence for which the term of imprisonment could be at least one year;
  • trafficking in a controlled substance, or making or possessing a large amount of drugs;

Sex and Violence

  • peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, and trafficking persons;
  • murder, rape, or sexual abuse of a minor, (having a sexual relationship with a child is not allowed in the United States, even if both parties are children);
  • child pornography;
  • owning, controlling, managing, or supervising a prostitution business;
  • transporting someone for the purpose of prostitution, if committed for commercial advantage;

Other

  • gambling offenses for which a sentence of one year imprisonment or more could be imposed;
  • an offense for demanding or accepting ransom;
  • failure to appear in court for sentencing if the associated crime could be punishable by imprisonment for a term of five years or more;
  • obstruction of justice, perjury or subornation of perjury (telling lies under oath), or bribing a witness, for which the term of imprisonment is at least one year;
  • an offense relating to a failure to appear before a court pursuant (order) to answer or dispose of a felony charge for which a sentence of 2 years’ imprisonment or more could be imposed.

Sources: uscode.house.gov

Other Cancellation of Removal Options

If you do not qualify for standard cancellation of removal, you may still qualify for other solutions. You are not limited to one application. In fact, you can apply for anything for which you qualify. For example, if you are a victim of domestic violence or another crime, you may apply for VAWA or U nonimmigrant status. Alternatively, a qualifying family member could apply for you within the family-based system. 

A good immigration attorney can help you determine your best options.

VAWA Cancellation of Removal

VAWA cancellation of removal helps immigrant victims of domestic violence leave their abusers. To qualify, your abuser must be: 

  • your spouse, who is either a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident; or
  • someone who you believed was your spouse but is not actually your spouse due to bigamy. This person must also be either a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident.

Alternatively, you may qualify for VAWA cancellation of removal if you have a child with a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident who abuses that child. In this case, you do not have to be married to the abuser. 

One advantage of VAWA is that you need only three years of physical presence. Also, you continue accruing time even after you have been put into deportation. Also, if you are not married to your abuser, you may still qualify for VAWA if they are a United States citizen and you have a child together who is also being abused. Learn More

Asylum

Asylum protects people who cannot return to their home country due to fear of being persecuted because of their race, religion, national origin, political opinion, or particular social group. Usually, you must apply for asylum within one year of entering the United States. However, you may still qualify for asylum if things have recently changed in your home country and you now fear returning due to this type of persecution. Learn More

U Nonimmigrant Status

U nonimmigrant status is designed to help law enforcement investigate crimes. It protects people who are victims of certain crimes if they cooperate with the police. If you qualify for U nonimmigrant status, you should start the process as soon as possible. Unfortunately, because U nonimmigrant status applications can take many years to process, the court may not let you wait in the United States until it is approved. However, starting your U nonimmigrant status while you are still here is important. Learn More

Family-Based Petition

United States citizens and green card holders can petition for certain family members to get lawful permanent residency. If you have a qualifying family member, ask them to petition for you. Often spouses petition for one another, but if you marry while in deportation, Immigration will suspect marriage fraud. In these cases they will often interview you to determine whether your marriage is legitimate or not.

Regardless of your relationship, family-based petitions can get a little complicated because different people approve certain parts of your application. Only Immigration can process your application for the immigrant visa. Separately, only the immigration judge can approve your application for a green card. This is another reason why having a good lawyer is so important.

Lastly, if your family-based petition puts you in the priority system, you will still have to wait until your priority date is current before you can receive your immigrant visa. If your priority date is several years away, the court might not allow you to wait for it in the United States. This situation will often vary because many judges have different time frames that they can allow cases to remain open.

Learn more on our Family Based Green Cards page.

Statistics

Detained Immigrants with Lawyers are:

0 x
More Likely to be Released from Detention
0 x
More Likely to Obtain Immigration Relief

Seek the Help of a Good Lawyer

We Can't Stress This Enough

If you are in deportation, now more than ever, you need the help of an experienced and honest Immigration attorney. Immigration law is detailed and complicated, and we urge you to rely on a well-trained lawyer for help.

Additional Resources

Family Based Green Card

Family based immigration helps unite families who want to be together. However, not all relatives are able to apply for one another. Before you attempt to petition for a family member, it is important to understand if you can petition through the Immediate Family Member of a U.S. Citizen or if you must use the Priority System. Read More about “Family Based Green Card”

VAWA Cancellation of Removal

The cancellation of removal for immigrant victims of domestic violence is often called VAWA cancellation. VAWA (Violence Against Women Act) cancellation is available to both men and women. If you qualify for this special deportation defense, Immigration will overlook certain aspects of your case that would otherwise prevent you from obtaining a green card. For example, you do not have to be in the United States for as long as other green card or cancellation of removal applicants. Read More about “VAWA Cancellation of Removal”